Best Steak Knives Review with Buying Guide

best-steak-knives-review

There is nothing I love more than cooking. A lot of cooks say that as much as they enjoy cooking and the amalgamation of flavors and scents, the one thing they usually despise is the process of cutting. Yes, it is possible to have the chopping and slicing tasks done by someone else, but when you’re looking for perfection, there is nothing better than your own judgement. Only your expert hands know how uniformly you want each slice to be cut or how finely you want every shred to be julienned. I personally enjoy the process of chopping, cutting and slicing a lot. And to make sure it remains fun, I always keep a good set of knives ready and clean. When it comes to steaks, however, it’s a whole other story. If you’re a steak lover, you have to own a proper steak knife. No matter how juicy, how tender or how well your steak is done, if you want to make sure all that meat flavour and texture stays intact, there is absolutely no other way to go. You need to get a good steak knife set.

Why Do I Need a Specialized Steak Knife?

A lot of people have popped this question at me. Is it really necessary to have a good quality steak knife? Well, yea, in the end you do use it to just cut your steak into pieces and pop them into your mouth. But try cutting a really well cooked steak with a steak knife and a regular knife and you’ll immediately notice the difference in taste. It has to do with the surface area of contact, material of construction of the blade as well the amount of pressure applied to the meat while cutting. The best way to have a steak would obviously be to use your own bare hands. But you see we live in a civilized society and don’t want to be labelled as barbaric. If you want a complete, and elegant dining experience, the last thing you would need is having to wrestle with the meat to have a piece of it! Moral of the story, yes, you do need a good steak knife, be it to have a good dining experience, or give others a great dining experience.

best steak knives review
Source – Pixabay

What do I need to keep in mind when buying a steak knife?

 
Material of the Blade:
Steak knives cannot be confused with regular kitchen knives. Each of these cannot be used in place of the other. You mostly use a kitchen knife on a wooden or plastic board, which does not blunt out the knife edges. Steak knives, however, are used on ceramic plates, which usually tend to be hard and can dull out the edges of the knife from contact pretty quickly. Moreover, the salt content in the meat adds further insult to the poor knife’s injury (Talk about rubbing salt in the wound!) As such, your steak knife has to be tough enough to take on a good beating for at least a year.

Sharpness:

Make sure your knife is sharp. The last thing you want to see is your meat go flying off the plate while trying to cut it. A good steak knife can even cut through tough meat and gristle easily. In fact, contrary to common belief, the sharper your knife blade is the safer it is, since it cuts much more precisely and you can slice down in one go

Stain Resistance:

Your steak knife should also be stain resistant. As I had mentioned before, the salt and oil content, along with spices and other condiments in the food tends to wear out, corrode and stain the knife quite fast. I would, therefore advise you to go for a steak knife that is stain and rust proof. A good quality stainless steel is a good material for the knife’s blade. Avoid knives made from carbon blades, as they rust easily and ceramic knives tend to be brittle.

Handle:

It’s not only the blade of the knife that needs attention. The handle or grip of the knife plays an equally important role in the overall experience of the knife. A good steak knife should have a good, heavy handle, so you can slice through easily and more precisely. The grip should also be shaped to be conveniently snuggled in your hand while you hold it. It needs to both look and feel good.

Serrated or Straight edge?

Serrated, micro-serrated or straight edge?  I have gone through numerous steak knife reviews and found that people are mostly divided in this choice. Fans of the serrated knife swear by it, while a fan of the straight edge knife will tell you there’s nothing smoother than a cut with a straight edge knife. If you ask me, a serrated knife does have its pros, as its sharpness lasts longer owing to less surface area of contact between the knife and the plate, whereas the straight edge knife gives a more even cut, avoiding the need to saw through the steak, which does tend to shred it a bit. But hey, to each his/her own!

Fit

One red flag when purchasing a new set of steak knives is the fit. By fit, I mean how well all the knife’s components are combined together, so there’s no visible gap that can be seen between the handle and the blade. A good knife should be solid bolster and basically seamless. This is an indicator of the knife’s longevity as well as its susceptibility to infiltration of fluids, moisture and contaminants in the gaps.

Balance

Another important red flag is the balance of the knife. In my opinion, one should always physically be able to pick up, hold and feel the knife before making a purchase. This is something that will not be possible when shopping online. Since you will be dishing out a good amount of cash on these knives, it would be wiser to test them out so you’re not dealing with a useless set of knives that you just spent a fortune on.

Look

The last thing you should obviously look out for is how the knife looks overall. If you want to impress your guests, or if you want to enjoy your own dining experience, it is important to have a nice set of good-looking knives laid out in front of you. There are numerous types of steak knife sets available nowadays, and you can get the ones which most match the theme you are looking out for. You want a rustic theme, get a set of knives with wooden handles. For a high-end look, you can go for those made from bone or horn, while a modern theme would warrant the use of shiny brushed aluminium handles.
Now that you know what you should look for in a fresh set of steak knives, let’s take a look at some of the sets available in the market that, I believe, are worthy of purchase:

15 Top Rated Steak Knife Sets That You Need on Your Table

  1. AmazonBasics Premium 8-Piece Steak Knife Set:

These knives are very exquisite and really enhance the beauty of my kitchen. They are made from stain-resistant steel which makes them ideal for regular use. The edge of the blade of the knives are micro-serrated, so it’s quite convenient for me as they don’t need me to sharpen them after every few uses. The finish is nice and quality is also just incredible. This is one of the best set of knives I’ve used so far, especially for this price. It is full tang has a nice and strong riveted handle, good solid bolster, is quite well-balanced and is a single piece construction, for this price it is absolutely a win-win. It feels magnificently sturdy in my hand. I guess I have the full solid bolster and full tang to thank for this. This is one of my go-to knife sets at the moment for any party as I don’t need to worry if a guest spoils or breaks my knife. I needed this knife to cut meat in family bbq functions and it does the job better than I expected. When I ordered this, I had a doubt on the quality as the price was so cheap according to the quantity, like can you believe getting a steak knife for less than $3!! It’s insane. But to my surprise this is far more than what I expected, this really gets me compliments when I serve them at my dinner parties. It does its job perfectly and smoothly. 66% of its users have given this set 5 stars. I would recommend this knife to everyone, especially to those who want to buy a budget friendly, yet incredible steak knife.

job better than I expected. When I ordered this, I had a doubt on the quality as the price was so cheap according to the quantity, like can you believe getting a steak knife for less than $3!! It’s insane. But to my surprise this is far more than what I expected, this really gets me compliments when I serve them at my dinner parties. It does its job perfectly and smoothly. 66% of its users have given this set 5 stars. I would recommend this knife to everyone, especially to those who want to buy a budget friendly, yet incredible steak knife.

Pros Cons
  • Quite sharp
  • Never needs sharpening
  • Good balance
  • Good looking
  • Solid bolster
  • Low cost
  • Cannot handle tougher meats
  • Meat tends to shred a little due to micro-serrated edges
Customer Review:

“I bought this set on an impulse, since I found the price to be low, so I thought why not give it a shot! Well, I’m so glad I did! These knives are sharp! I so hate the idea of sharpening knives! I’ve had these for more than 8 months now, and they’re still as sharp as the first day I bought them”.

  1. Dalstrong Steak Knives Set:

These knives are made up of an incredible quality of stain resistant German steel. German steel has gained a good reputation and is, in itself, a sign of great quality. The knives are a bit bigger in size so everyone may not be comfortable while using it at the dinner table, especially those who are not accustomed to using heavy knives. But these are one of the best knives to cut meat in the kitchen, especially larger portions of meat. They come with a lifetime warranty for the cutlery against manufacturing defects. These straight edged knives just do the job more perfectly than serrated edge knives. They cut through smoothly without you having to saw through it. That’s actually one of the reasons they are built heavy. Dalstrong knives supplement the beauty of any meal of the day, they cut through even the toughest of meat like butter. Although they are little bigger in size, they are well balanced, and the grip of the handle is just mind blowing. After a lot of research and seeing all the reviews on Amazon I bought these knives, and I have to say, I was quite impressed. The knives have 91 percent customer satisfaction. Goes to show how well received they are by customers

Pros Cons
  • Built from premium quality German steel
  • Cuts through meat very smoothly
  • Solid bolster
  • Comes with a matching sheath for protection
  • Luxury black pakkawood handle, with ergonomic design for a good hold
  • Quite heavy
  • Expensive
Customer Review:

“I absolutely love this set! Yes, I splurged out a good amount of cash on this, but as they say, you get what you pay for. My husband had advised me not to dish out so much on a set of knives. But, come on! It’s premium quality German Steel! Now my husband just enjoys his steak, without a word, but with a smile on his face.”

  1. J.A. Henckels International Stainless Steel 8-Piece Steak Knife Set:

These knives come with serrated edge blades. That way, the makers could keep the knife lighter and still allow you to cut into meat. My preference for straight edge and serrated edge knives for steak keeps interchanging. I sometimes prefer serrated edge over straight edge, simply because I don’t like the idea of sharpening knives every now and then. These knives can be washed in the dishwasher. The other advantage is obviously that they don’t have a tendency to blunt out easily owing to the lesser surface area of contact with the plate. The handles of these knives are polished stainless steel, giving them an almost aristocratic look. I personally find the design quite fashionable and sleek. Almost 80% of the people who bought these knives are highly satisfied with their performance. They are made of up superior calibre German steel. These knives can be washed very easily without much effort, and they still have the mirror finish on the blade after several months of using. The Zwilling knives are so lightweight and thin especially, the sharp edge of the knife helps to cut even the toughest portion of meat with ease. The person using the knife should be very careful, though as the edges are sharp. Overall, I liked the feel of these knives in my hand, and at this price, I’ll recommend everyone to give it a try if you are looking for something graceful yet sharp.

Pros Cons
  • Corrosion resistant
  • One-piece construction with full tang
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Low cost
  • Sleek and lightweight
  • Serrated edges, so need less frequent sharpening
  • Both blade and handle are stainless steel, so they look good and also make the knife longer lasting.
  • Tips of the blade may be a bit fragile
Customer Review:

“These knives certainly do live up to their name. Although I prefer straight edged steak knives, I find it hard to find time to sharpen them time and again, especially since I’m a mother of three. In spite of having a serrated blade, I find these knives quite smooth on the meat. The knives require minimum up-keep as they tend to rust less as well. I just pop them in the dishwasher, so I don’t have to worry about manually washing them either”.

  1. Wusthof 8-Piece Stainless-Steel Steak Knife Set with Wooden Gift Box:

The first thing I noticed about this set is the packaging. The captivating mahogany box that it came in, along with that elegant velvet lining gave it such a luxurious oomph. Felt like I was opening some sort of a treasure chest. Apart from the look and feel, the presence of the box makes it easier to store the 8 piece knife set and keep them protected from air and moisture which could cause rusting. The edges of the knives are serrated, so they cut through meat very easily without the need for frequent sharpening. These make the perfect gift. In fact, I had gifted this to a friend for her wedding and she has been using the set for over a year now. She gave me quite positive vibes about it. Each knife is about 9 inches in length. Since the make of the knife blades are of carbon, it is prone to rusting. So, I would suggest you to steer clear of the dishwasher. However, these knives are really heavy and strong, in spite of being quite slim. This will make sure that the blades cut through the meat with much more precision and smoothness. They are comfortable to use as the blades are very sharp, solid and thick. Another great side of these knives is that they can go with any type of dinner set, be it formal or casual. In spite of the price, the set has been able to acquire a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Not bad, I would say.

Pros Cons
  • Precision forged
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Sleek and modern look
  • Goes well with any flatware
  • One piece metal with no seams
  • Comes in a great mahogany box
  • Serrated edges, so need less maintenance
  • Expensive
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Not resistant to corrosion

Customer Review:

“These knives are just great! They are nice and weighty enough to cut into my steak, but not so much that I find it hard to hold. These knives don’t just look good, they are also well-designed and do the job well. I also love the luxe box that these knives come in. Impresses my guests when I take them out from the box in front of them. Yes, I like to show off. They have the perfect finish and I do give them a bit of TLC as I want them to remain as good as new forever.”

  1. Messermeister Avanta 4-Piece Fine Edge Steak Knife Set:

If you have a small family or plan to host a cosy small party for a couple, this set would be a great option. This 4 piece steak knife set has elegant looking knives, each of which have been crafted with a fine edge, yet they cut through any meat like butter. The quality of these knives is magnificent, they are made up of German steel, one of the toughest and finest material, which is also rust-resistant. The handles are made of resin-impregnated wood, which guarantees strength and quality, but also means that you have to handwash them, instead of slipping them into the dishwasher. You can sharpen these knives if needed as they have a fine edge, but you can use them a lot before they dull out. I found that some people reviewed about receiving the package with cracked handles and other problems but I got mine intact. Yes, it would have been more convenient if they were a set of 8 or 6, but for the quality and the price that Messermeister offers for this, set, I think it’s quite a bargain! I keep a set of these for when my husband and I are in the mood for a rustic double date with my bestie, or a friend of his since more often than not, steak is a common dish at these parties

Pros Cons
  • Rust-resistant
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Easy to sharpen
  • Full tang, good balance and heft
  • Cuts smoothly, instead of tearing
  • Low cost
  • Made from German High Carbon Stainless Steel
  • Perfect for both cutting boneless meat as well as deboning
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Small set (only 4 pieces)

Customer Review:

I’m not really that much of a party hosting person. But I do love to have a good meal at dinner with my own family. We’re a family of 4, so this is just about perfect for us. These knives cut very well and feel comfortable to hold. I do need to sharpen them after every 10 uses or so, but that’s because I always like to keep them razor sharp. If you’re not that much of a perfectionist, you could probably go longer without sharpening”.

  1. Cuisinart C55-6PCSBK Advantage Color Collection 6-Piece Ceramic Coated Steak Knife Set:

This dapper looking knife set can make any table look upscale and swanky. They come in different colors, like black, white and red, but I found the black steak knife totally takes the cake. These stainless steel knives are coated with ceramic which not only makes them look good but makes carving of the steak easier. Ceramic knives are notorious for being brittle, but these knives have a shielding of stainless steel under them, which gives them the goodness and benefits of both. Moreover, the ceramic coating also makes it non-stick, so you can say goodbye to staining or having pieces of steak stuck to your knife while cutting. At first look you would be misled to think that these knives must be really expensive. But you’ll be totally taken aback when you hear the price. It’s so cheap for the quality and I can easily wash them in a dishwasher which makes my work so much more effortless. The knives are serrated, so they don’t need re-sharpening. These are sharp enough to even be used to cut through raw meats especially chicken. In fact, these knives can beat the knives which are 3 times more expensive than them, both in the looks department, as well as in terms of functionality.

Pros Cons
  • Non-stick coating
  • Come with protective sleeves
  • Ergonomic handles
  • Low cost
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Attractive looks and come in fun colors
  • Serrated edge, so no need of sharpening
  • 01. Serrated edge causes meat to tear a little while cutting

Customer Review:

“I got this set as a wedding gift, and I find it quite useful. The knives not only brighten up my table, they work great too. In fact, I usually use these as my multipurpose knives. I cut fruits, vegetables and bread with them, spread butter with them, and at the end of the day, present them at the dinner table as a steak knife. I’m learning to be nifty already you see!”

  1. Foxel Black Steak Knives Set of 6 or 12 Gift Box:

This set is packaged beautifully enough to be gifted to a family member, friend or acquaintance. They are a set of simple, yet elegant knives, with just enough weight to give a full-bodied hold and an ergonomic design, with curves at just the right places to ensure a steady grip of the handle. The handles are full tang and triple riveted, that feel really luxurious in my hand. Most of the people who bought this set say that it’s a real bargain, considering that you can get these at such an affordable rate compared to most steak knife sets. Cherry on the cake is that these knives last for a really long time, almost a lifetime, at least that’s what most reviews say. They come with a choice of both straight edged as well as serrated edge blades, so you can take your pick according to the type of blade edge you are most comfortable with. The tips of the blades are sturdy and enough, in that, they don’t bend tend to bend at the tips over time, as most steak knives do. I always handwash my knives, even if it takes time as I’m really picky and sensitive about my steaks, and I would advise you to do the same. Almost 85% of the Amazon customers who have used this set are highly satisfied with the quality and performance of these knives.
Pros Cons
  • Great Packaging in a box
  • Reasonable cost
  • Sturdy blade tips
  • Ergonomic handles
  • Sturdy blade tips
  • 1-year satisfaction guarantee
  • Full tang and triple riveted handles
  • Not dishwasher safe

Customer Review:

“I bought the 12 piece knife set as I wanted it for a party involving a large number of guest and I was in shortage of steak knives. These seemed quite good according to the price and they also complemented the other dishware that I wanted to present in front of the guest for the bbq party. They help you cut any type of steak effortlessly and make me look like a really thoughtful host in the end!”

  1. Wüsthof Gourmet 6-Piece Steak-Knife Set:

The Wüsthof brand has become a household name for knives, especially steak knives. They are always on the lookout for newer and better knife designs to grace our any dinner table. This one is a set of 6-piece gourmet knives that are made from high-quality stainless steel. You can sharpen them anytime you need, though you wouldn’t need to that much, if you eat steak sparingly (who eats steak every day anyway!). You will love using these knives as they glide through any meat cleanly and effortlessly. These knives are quite lightweight, but still, they do the job as perfectly as they should according to the price. The blades do not have any serration at the front as shown in the picture, which was a bit of a disappointment to me, but nevertheless they do the job well. Germans are known worldwide for their exquisite cutlery and silverware products. I’ve always loved using knives from Wüsthof and this no exception. The knives will serve you longer if you hand wash them and dry them with a cloth instead of putting them in a dishwasher. Considering a brand such as Wüsthof, I would say the price of these are more along the lower end. The only downside, I would say is the handle. The handle is made from plastic, but with rivets. However, that is also understandable, since the lower price, as compared to other Wüsthof knife sets compensates for it.
Pros Cons
  • Good quality stainless steel blades
  • Reasonable cost
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Very sharp
  • Good shape for precision cutting
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Handle could have been of a better quality
  • Light weight (I find this a disadvantage, many may find it an advantage), giving the user a feeling that it is cheap.

Customer Review:

“I’ve been using these knives for two years now, and I’m highly satisfied with the quality. While searching for this I saw the classic steak knives from Wusthof, which look similar to these but these gourmet ones are available at a much lower price. True, you can’t compare the two qualities, but this set is at least one that fits my budget and I have to say, there has been no disappointment so far.”

Bottom Line

To sum up, there are numerous brands available in the market, each one catering to different types of steak lovers. Some like it heavy, others like it slim. Some like straight-edge blades, while others like serrated edges. In my opinion, it does not matter what type of knife you purchase, as long as it matches your budget, your need and your purpose of use. It is important though to weigh out the pros and cons. Sometimes a pro is one area may mean having to deal with a con in another. I have tried to give reviews of the best knives sets in my opinion. I’m not claiming to have the best opinion in the world, but I have tried to provide you with as much of an informed one as possible.

If you ask me, my favorite is Dalstrong Steak Knives 4-piece Set. Each knife is a solid bolster one-piece stainless steel beauty that looks good with my other flatware. Every piece is a premium quality knife. With my little family of 4, this set is perfect. The edges remain sharp for a very long time and they get my meat cut as quick as a flash so it’s ready to enter my palate. It comes in these elegant sheathes, making it safe for me to store and handle. The company also offers customized boxes with luxury packaging for presenting these as birthday, wedding or anniversary gifts. Sure, it costs a little more, but if these knives are going to serve me for a lifetime, I don’t mind giving in to a little indulgence.

I hope that this information has helped you in deciding on the best steak knife for you, or at least helped you understand what it means to own a set of good quality steak knives.

0 Comments
Share

reviewadmin

Reply your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*